Transition Towns vs. WorldChanging
I came across this article a while ago. Today I’m doing research in preparation for promoting a new book on the Transition movement, and I came across it again. It’s a haughty screed by Alex Steffen of the sort-of now defunct but very awesome and optimistic WorldChanging organization.
http://www.worldchanging.com/archives/010672.html
I finally figured out what bothers me about it. It’s his elitist snobbery, utterly poo-poohing the efforts of Transition folks. Like this:
The Transition movement seems saturated with what Michael Lerner called “surplus powerlessness” disguised as practicality. All over the world, groups of people with graduate degrees, affluence, decades of work experience, varieties of advanced training and technological capacities beyond the imagining of our great-grandparents are coming together, looking into the face of apocalypse… and deciding to start a seed exchange or a kids clothing swap.
He means this to sound credible, even important…but it’s hard to shake the feeling that he’s yet another extremely privileged person blaming the victim.
News flash buddy. People do feel so disempowered and disconnected from their neighbors and from the resource streams that sustain them that a seed exchange or clothing swap can truly be a life-changing experience. It’s not okay to call that pathetic.
At first I agreed with Steffen, thinking, Oh yeah hm, it’s true, a kids clothing swap won’t save the planet. We need to think bigger. We need like, some experts to come save us with new technologies and stuff…waitaminute!
NO! No no no, Alex Steffen. We do not need more smartypants know-it-alls telling us what will save us, or inventing what will save us and then selling it to us. We need exactly what Transition offers. We need to come together in small groups and rediscover what it means to be earthlings, animals and humans. We need to feel what it is to find power in the seemingly small but radical acts of growing food and helping one another without corporate middle men taking our money along the way. This article sniffs disdainfully at how Transition groups
offer a way to step out of emotional paralysis by saying “just go ahead and do something, anything.” Part of it is intentional: groups spread more rapidly when the demands placed on their members are minimal.
But I’m telling you, that emotional paralysis is real. Maybe you don’t know. If you’ve never been emotionally paralyzed, you’re not special, you’re not better than those of us who have been. You’re LUCKY. You should be grateful, but you should not be so dismissive of empowerment.
To me, Transition is about more than just peak oil and energy crises. It’s about a more holistic sort of community well-being. It’s about happiness. Who can shake a stick at happiness? This guy, apparently.
The article quotes some prominent Transition folks, mis-characterizing them as “gleefully” awaiting the apocalypse. Again, like most of the article, it’s just mean-spirited, and ignorant of the privileged mindset that created it.
Peak oil and climate change, as ideas, really can do crazy things to people when they start to understand them. The two are intertwined in the origins of Transition, and I know from my own experiences that you can’t consider them seriously without suffering a bit of a revelation. Peak oil and climate change CHANGE the game as we’ve been playing it our whole lives (I’m 28). They change the game our parents, our grandparents, and their parents played. We don’t have an especially good grasp of history, we millennial humans, so that means we’re entering into a completely unknown and terrifying reality. Nobody knows when, or how extreme it will be, or how fast, but it’s coming, and it’s scary.
Transition accepts this and works with it. It doesn’t gleefully await the destruction that’s bound to come with any abrupt energy collapse. What can be done about that anyway? I guess that’s where the Transition stream diverges from the Alex Steffen stream significantly. The Steffen stream sees a technological messiah coming to save us all, and the Transition stream sees the world more for what it is (I think).
That world is full of citizen-consumers with hardly a lick of power to their names, even if they are educated and fairly affluent. Votes don’t matter, protests don’t matter, nothing matters. But home does, and family does, and neighbors do. And love does. And compassion does. And you know what? Food does too. Transition starts from these simple bases and builds…well, whatever the community needs.
It isn’t hegemonic, it isn’t high-tech. It isn’t prescriptive, and it doesn’t look the same from town to town. That’s the true beauty of it. Transition is merely people, coming together to find their power and how to determine just a little bit of their own destiny. This is something culture at large and politics at large have failed to offer us earthlings.
But we’re starting to figure out how to take it back.